How wide the Grey Dogs?

[mm5aho]

What size of boat can get through the Grey Dogs (that little gap just north of Scarba) ?
What depth is there?

[Telo]

Nick's been through on Fairwinds, I believe.

[wully]

I watched a 45' + sail boat motor out through.....

Google kayaking in the Grey Dogs to see what you'll get if your tide calcs are out.

Theres plenty depth.











Between the rocks.

[DaveS]

I agree. I've been through a couple of times in my 30 footer and I'd be happy to do so with a much bigger boat.

From the hill on Scarba I've watched kayakers being caught in the Grey Dogs and spat out into the Sound of Luing - looked like fun!

[DaveS]

I agree. I've been through a couple of times in my 30 footer and I'd be happy to do so with a much bigger boat.

Just to add to that: my charts are on the boat, but I've a VMH sub. and looking at the relevant chart there on maximum zoom it looks similar in size to the paper chart. I measure just over 2mm on screen between the 10m contour lines at the narrowest point and the chart is 1:25,000 so, assuming the screen image is the same as the paper chart, that represents 50m.

[wully]

I agree. I've been through a couple of times in my 30 footer and I'd be happy to do so with a much bigger boat.

From the hill on Scarba I've watched kayakers being caught in the Grey Dogs and spat out into the Sound of Luing - looked like fun!

Yer a braver man than me Dave- the thought of getting it wrong in mah wee boatie doesn't bear thinking about.

[claymore]

Wee Davey has Big Balls

[mm5aho]

I'm going to be over there again at the end of June, so if the tide permits (direction) I'll sneak a look in and see how navigable it is for me.
Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

[DaveS]

Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

I've not been into loch Etive yet - I'm feart of the 33 kV line E of the bridge. What's your air draft?

[Telo]

Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

I've not been into loch Etive yet - I'm feart of the 33 kV line E of the bridge. What's your air draft?

I thought the problem for your mast is the bridge itself. Even your mast would easily clear the leccy lines. I took a photograph and marked in the lines so that you can see clearance by passing close to the north/west side. I'll have a look for the pic - it's on an old thread.

[Telo]

Loch Etive thread - viewtopic.php?f=2&t=4939

[wully]

Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

I've not been into loch Etive yet - I'm feart of the 33 kV line E of the bridge. What's your air draft?

We kayaked in there last weekend, stunningly beautiful it was.
Found a deserted beach to camp on, had a barbie, fed the midges, ogled the scenery.
Paddled back out down wind and tide.
Nice.

From my yak the cables looked easily do- able and I've seen a fairly big ship in loading at the mine.

Being a big wus I don't fancy The Falls of Lora unless at slack neaps although a year or so ago I watched the mussel farm boat shoot the falls on a big ebb- much respect.
BTW, the first part of the loch is littered with mussel ropes in every little bay but they, and the houses get less and less the farther in you go.( we didn't have time to get all the way to the end, that's for another trip)

http://www.fallsoflora.info has some good foaties and info on the tides.

[DaveS]

Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

I've not been into loch Etive yet - I'm feart of the 33 kV line E of the bridge. What's your air draft?

I thought the problem for your mast is the bridge itself. Even your mast would easily clear the leccy lines. I took a photograph and marked in the lines so that you can see clearance by passing close to the north/west side. I'll have a look for the pic - it's on an old thread.

Well, according to the plate in the boat its air draught is 14m, but that's the mast head, and aerials and things probably add another metre, so call it 15m. The chart gives the bridge clearance as 14m and the power line safe clearance as 13m. (IIRC these are measured from MHWS.) I don't have access here to the proper tidal information for Connel, but Easytide shows only a 0.5m difference in high water over the next 7 days. At neaps a HW passage under the bridge might be possible, but if so I think I'd then want to wait until low water before going under the power line, which would increase clearance by 1.5m. I entirely accept the point about keeping well to the north to avoid the sag. However, the underlying worry is that getting it wrong and clipping the bridge might cost me my VHF aerial, whereas getting it wrong with the power line would probably be terminal.

[DaveS]

Can't be much worse than surfing down the Falls of Lora?

I've not been into loch Etive yet - I'm feart of the 33 kV line E of the bridge. What's your air draft?

We kayaked in there last weekend, stunningly beautiful it was.
Found a deserted beach to camp on, had a barbie, fed the midges, ogled the scenery.
Paddled back out down wind and tide.
Nice.

From my yak the cables looked easily do- able and I've seen a fairly big ship in loading at the mine.

Being a big wus I don't fancy The Falls of Lora unless at slack neaps although a year or so ago I watched the mussel farm boat shoot the falls on a big ebb- much respect.
BTW, the first part of the loch is littered with mussel ropes in every little bay but they, and the houses get less and less the farther in you go.( we didn't have time to get all the way to the end, that's for another trip)

http://www.fallsoflora.info has some good foaties and info on the tides.

What a useful site! Now the only missing bit of critical information is Connel MHWS, which I'm sure is in the pilot, but that's on board the boat. Anyone know?

[Alan_D]

Well, according to the plate in the boat its air draught is 14m, but that's the mast head, and aerials and things probably add another metre, so call it 15m. The chart gives the bridge clearance as 14m and the power line safe clearance as 13m. (IIRC these are measured from MHWS.)

If it is a recent chart they will be measured from HAT, which is significantly higher than MHWS, so you may have more room than you think.

As an aside, why do multi-storey car-parks and similar structures display notices like "Max Headroom 2.3 metres" when what they mean is minimum headroom?