Page 1 of 1
Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Sep 20, 2012 11:44 am
by Nick
.
The application for the proposed 9-turbine Clachan windfarm adjacent to Puilladobhran was considered by Argyll & Bute's planning committee yesterday. They recommended the application for refusal but deferred the final decision to a Discretionary Hearing because of the degree of public interest. This will take place ‘locally’ probably after a site visit by the Councillors. Members of the public will be able to attend and speak at this meeting.
(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Fri Sep 21, 2012 8:35 pm
by Arghiro
Nick wrote:.
The application for the proposed 9-turbine Clachan windfarm adjacent to Puilladobhran was considered by Argyll & Bute's planning committee yesterday. They recommended the application for refusal but deferred the final decision to a Discretionary Hearing because of the degree of public interest. This will take place ‘locally’ probably after a site visit by the Councillors. Members of the public will be able to attend and speak at this meeting.
(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)
That does look nice.
I do think that windmills add much graceful movement to any otherwise empty landscape. Sadly, given the usual weather in that area I doubt that many will be lucky enough to see them thro the cloud & mist.
Anyway, I hope you are successful in encoraging the ivestment in sustainable energy, which will bring much needed income to the landowner & reduce his dependence on sheep.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Fri Sep 21, 2012 8:52 pm
by marisca
Arghiro wrote:Nick wrote:.
The application for the proposed 9-turbine Clachan windfarm adjacent to Puilladobhran was considered by Argyll & Bute's planning committee yesterday. They recommended the application for refusal but deferred the final decision to a Discretionary Hearing because of the degree of public interest. This will take place ‘locally’ probably after a site visit by the Councillors. Members of the public will be able to attend and speak at this meeting.
(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)
That does look nice.
I do think that windmills add much graceful movement to any otherwise empty landscape. Sadly, given the usual weather in that area I doubt that many will be lucky enough to see them thro the cloud & mist.
Anyway, I hope you are successful in encoraging the ivestment in sustainable energy, which will bring much needed income to the landowner & reduce his dependence on sheep.
Can ye shag a windmill?
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Sun Sep 23, 2012 9:15 pm
by Pete Cooper
marisca wrote:
Can ye shag a windmill?
Didn't Donald Trump use some images of well shagged wind turbines?
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 7:23 pm
by Clyde_Wanderer
(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)[/quote]
That explains why all the blades are stopped in the exact same position.
I think its a false representation of a true windfarm!
C_W
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Oct 04, 2012 10:01 pm
by Arghiro
Clyde_Wanderer wrote:(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)
That explains why all the blades are stopped in the exact same position.
I think its a false representation of a true windfarm!
C_W[/quote]
They seem to have forgoten the scenic drive roadways betwwen them too.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Fri Oct 05, 2012 10:07 pm
by Clyde_Wanderer
Arghiro wrote:Clyde_Wanderer wrote:(the image above is a photomontage produced by the local windfarm opposition group)
That explains why all the blades are stopped in the exact same position.
I think its a false representation of a true windfarm!
C_W
They seem to have forgoten the scenic drive roadways betwwen them too.[/quote]
And the shadows!
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Sat Oct 13, 2012 10:24 am
by sahona
Clyde_Wanderer wrote:
And the shadows!
Are they there?
I can't hear a thing.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Sat Oct 13, 2012 10:50 pm
by Arghiro
sahona wrote:Clyde_Wanderer wrote:
And the shadows!
Are they there?
I can't hear a thing.
Why would you? They go pretty slowly.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2012 10:45 am
by Nick
.
The application was unanimously rejected yesterday by the planning committee.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2012 1:18 pm
by DaveS
Nick wrote:.
The application was unanimously rejected yesterday by the planning committee.
Presumably, though, the Scottish Government can over-rule the planners. And given Eck's increasingly deranged view of the potential contribution of renewable generation, I would have thought it not unlikely.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2012 1:27 pm
by Nick
DaveS wrote:Nick wrote:.
The application was unanimously rejected yesterday by the planning committee.
Presumably, though, the Scottish Government can over-rule the planners. And given Eck's increasingly deranged view of the potential contribution of renewable generation, I would have thought it not unlikely.
Rory Young has invested a fair bit in this, so I guess he will pursue whatever avenues are open.
I am amazed that the Scottish government has time to look at every tinpot windfarm application - it's only 9MW ffs, hardly worth getting excited about.
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 7:15 pm
by BlowingOldBoots
The bays to the left and right, in front of Puilladobhran, (is it Applecross something or another) what is the charted water depth? They look like good anchorages as an alternative to Puilladobhran.
Thanks,
BlowingOldBoots
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 11:34 pm
by Clyde_Wanderer
BlowingOldBoots wrote:The bays to the left and right, in front of Puilladobhran, (is it Applecross something or another) what is the charted water depth? They look like good anchorages as an alternative to Puilladobhran.
Thanks,
BlowingOldBoots
Too far from the Tigh
C_W
Re: Puilladobhran windfarm - update
Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2012 1:55 pm
by DaveS
BlowingOldBoots wrote:The bays to the left and right, in front of Puilladobhran, (is it Applecross something or another) what is the charted water depth? They look like good anchorages as an alternative to Puilladobhran.
Thanks,
BlowingOldBoots
Ardencaple Bay. Yes, I anchored there earlier this year. There's also space outside Puilladobhrain which would be a useful "overflow" in fairly calm conditions when P'n is full. The disadvantage as CW says is that it's a bit further to walk or row respectively to get to the pub.