Page 1 of 1

Westminster CG debate postponed until the last minute

Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2011 6:13 pm
by Nick
.
From JIM MATHER MSP (ARGYLL & BUTE)

9th March, 2011 for immediate release

KEY WESTMINSTER DEBATE ON COASTGUARD FUTURE “PULLED” AT SHORT NOTICE

Jim Mather, (MSP Argyll & Bute) has expressed dismay at the news that the House of Commons Backbench Business Committee has postponed a key debate on the future of UK Coastguard services that was due to be held on Thursday afternoon. The topic will not now be debated until March 24th which is the last day scheduled for the consultation process that proposes a radical and damaging reduction in the Coastguard service particularly in Scotland where it is proposed that only one fulltime station will be retained in Scotland at Aberdeen with a part time, daylight presence at either Shetland or Stornoway.

Jim Mather said:
“I share the concerns already very forcibly expressed by my colleague Angus MacNeil, MP, the SNP Transport spokesman at Westminster on this.

The Committee members-none of whom represent coastal constituencies – have postponed this crucial debate until the last day of the consultation process on Coastguard services when clearly such an opportunity to inform and guide such a vital decision for our coastal communities is essential. The utter disregard exhibited here by ditching this at less than 48 hours notice beggars belief and has to be questioned. If the Department of Transport were to extend the consultation period to allow the subject to be properly aired this could save the situation but the disdain already shown in this matter does not suggest that such a pragmatic solution is likely to be seriously considered.

My Westminster contacts advise me that it is unprecedented for a debate to be erased from the order paper in such a way at such short notice. There seems to be little or no perception down there of how essential Coastguard services are to our fishing, ferry, marine transport and to recreational sailing on our complex and extensive coastline and home waters and how important that a network of informed staff with local knowledge is available when required.

This serves to demonstrate yet again the need for the Scottish Parliament to take the fullest control of Scottish issues.”
Contact jim.mather.msp@scottish.parliament.uk

Re: Westminster CG debate postponed until the last minute

Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2011 8:09 pm
by Arghiro
Why would they want "open debate" when they have already made their decision. This is simply a way of avoiding dissent & sensible discussion. There will just be an announcement followed by a handfull of fobbed off questions, at least some of which will be planted by sympathetic lackey Govt MP's "Congratulating the Govt on saving money"

:goatd Bless our "elected representatives" :goatd

Re: Westminster CG debate postponed until the last minute

Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2011 11:45 pm
by Nick
Arghiro wrote:Why would they want "open debate" when they have already made their decision. This is simply a way of avoiding dissent & sensible discussion. There will just be an announcement followed by a handfull of fobbed off questions, at least some of which will be planted by sympathetic lackey Govt MP's "Congratulating the Govt on saving money"
Well thanks at least for a sensible reply Aghiro. I posted this on S'butt for information and all I got was a load of garbage about why didn't Scotland set up its own CG.

Re: Westminster CG debate postponed until the last minute

Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2011 11:39 am
by Arghiro
Yeah, I saw that & decided not to get involved. Too many right wing self-made men on there that believe everything the Tories tell them about "the need to cut costs".

I spent too long in an industry where the drive for "efficiencies" led to cock-up after cock-up as vital stages in various processes were eliminated to reduce "waste". The consequent mess was usually more difficult & costly to clean up than the "savings" proposed. That's what happens when you get top-down process design.

I'm pretty sure it will end in tears, but no-one is going to listen are they? I'd like to see a cross-party set-up with representatives from all branches of the CG do a "Start from scratch" exercise to assess what is really needed & then compare that with what we have & what we can afford. We might then get the "nice to haves" cut & the essentials kept. This all looks too half-cock for my liking.

Consultation period extended

Posted: Thu Mar 10, 2011 4:35 pm
by Nick
.
It has just been annopunced that the consultation period has been extended for six weeks until May 5th. Let's all take this opportunity to write to our MPs, sign petitions etc.